South African Minerals Belong to the People. So should their Future Value
Central to the country’s approach to mineral resources and our overall constitutional concept is the principle that mineral resources belong to all South Africans. According to Section 3 of the MPRDA mineral resources are the common heritage of all South Africans and the state acts as custodian thereof for the benefit of the public and future generations.
Some benefits are shared broadly and nationally, such as employment, community development, contribution to revenue, improved international relations and investment, socio-economic welfare and economic growth.
Custodianship in respect of mineral law is understood with reference to the MPRDA. Under this Act, the Minister acts on behalf of the state granting and administering mining rights and permits. Custodianship also require sustainable development of mineral resources, by balancing social, economic and environmental factors benefit present and future generations.
Moreover, the court in Agri SA v Minister for Minerals and Energy supports the idea that mineral wealth should be administered in the public interest by clarifying that the state acts as a facilitator of broader and equitable access to mineral resources as opposed to a competing owner of such resources.
Furthermore, sustainable development also entails protecting the environment for benefit of present and future generations by ensuring that mining supports long-term economic and social development. This includes ensuring that mining protects health, while improving access to education, healthcare and jobs even after the end of mineral resources extraction.
The Minister may also charge levy, including royalties and tax as per act of Parliament. The Royalty is paid to the National Revenue Fund, which is ultimately used to fund programmes for the citizens’ benefits.
The constitutional principle of public benefit under section 213 and s214 also provides guidance for how revenue from mineral resources is managed. Section 213 established the National Revenue Fund into which all funds generated by the state must be paid and regulates all withdrawals from it. In addition section 214provides for the equitable division national state revenue.
What mechanism can translate custodianship into durable public benefit? A sovereign wealth fund (SWF), a social wealth fund or an intergenerational fund?
A SWF is a state-owned investment fund that invests state-generated revenues and financial reserves abroad, usually to strengthen a country’s economy. By limiting money circulating domestically, this may protect the country’s economy from a commodity boom, thereby preventing inflation and protecting export industries. However, investing abroad may limit funds for urgent domestic needs such as infrastructure and education. The assumption is that if a country has access to international markets, profitable domestic projects should already be able to attract investment from elsewhere, the state does not need to use its resource revenues to fund those projects.
However, this may be less effective in developing countries such as South Africa, which face limited severe infrastructure and development needs, limited borrowing capacity and corruption. Policy makers need to clearly define the strategic objectives they intend with the SWF, whether to stabilise the economy, grow revenue, promote development or finance infrastructure. South Africa has not clearly identified which model best suits its circumstances.
Because resource revenues are inherently temporary, intergenerational funds try to resolve this by investing some of that temporary mineral income so that it produces a permanent stream of income and consuming only the sustainable returns. However, this is not feasible in developing countries, with asymmetric access to world capital. They can save more readily than they can borrow. Therefore, they should save more and opt for domestic investment which is cheaper than investing in foreign capital. Saving for future generations is more feasible when all debt has been cleared.
For instance, the Pacific Island of Nauru invested about 2/3 of its mining revenue into a fund for future wealth. This fund made poor and politically influenced investments including expensive projects with limited economic value, leading to the collapse of the fund. This illustrates that investing some resource revenue in domestic projects can help address infrastructure and financing shortages and limit spending recklessly.
A social wealth fund treats citizens as beneficiaries of collectively owned assets, using returns to finance public service and productive investment. The Royal Bafokeng Holdings community-based investment model is a great example. It manages the community’s platinum mining interests and mining investment to support community service delivery, such as electricity, water, schools and clinics. This model could be more appealing to a developing country like South Africa considering its level of inequality as it makes the connection between mineral wealth and citizens more visible.
Conclusion
South Africa should generate mineral wealth as a shared inheritance. Considering that our development needs, inequality and governance challenges investing in domestic assets could be beneficial to both current and future generations. A fund whose ultimate beneficiaries are South Africans with strict rules on spending and investment would be appropriate. Dometic investment, supported by a parking fund, as a temporary way of saving resource revenue when a country is not yet ready to spend the money efficiently can be useful. A parking fund could temporarily invest revenues abroad during resource booms and release them gradually as suitable projects and investment capacity improve. This would allow South Africa to meet current needs while preserving wealth for future generations.